' NCCG.ORG, FAQ 362. The Feast of John 5: Was it Purim?
Logo Copyright © 2007 NCCG - All Rights Reserved
Return to Main Page

RESOURCES

Disclaimer

Introduction

Symphony of Truth

In a Nutshell

Topical Guide

5-144000

5 Commissions

10 Commandments

333 NCCG Number

144,000, The

A

Action Stations

Agency, Free

Alcohol

Angels

Anointing

Apostles

Apostolic Interviews

Apostolic Epistles

Archive, Complete

Articles & Sermons

Atheism

Atonement

B

Banners

Baptism, Water

Baptism, Fire

Becoming a Christian

Bible Codes

Bible Courses

Bible & Creed

C

Calendar of Festivals

Celibacy

Charismata & Tongues

Chavurat Bekorot

Christian Paganism

Chrism, Confirmation

Christmas

Church, Fellowship

Contact us

Constitution

Copyright

Covenants & Vows

Critics

Culture

Cults

D

Deliverance

Demons

Desperation

Diaries

Discipleship

Dreams

E

Ephraimite Page, The

Essene Christianity

Existentialism

F

Faith

Family, The

Feminism

FAQ

Festivals of Yahweh

Festivals Calendar

Freedom

G

Gay Christians

Gnosticism

Godhead, The

H

Heaven

Heresy

Healing

Health

Hebrew Roots

Hell

Hinduism

History

Holiness

Holy Echad Marriage

Holy Order, The

Home Education

Homosexuality

Human Nature

Humour

Hymnody

I

Intro to NCCG.ORG

Islam

J

Jewish Page, The

Judaism, Messianic

Judaism, Talmudic

K

KJV-Only Cult

L

Links

Love

M

Marriage & Romance

Membership

Miracles

Messianic Judaism

Mormonism

Music

Mysticism

N

NCCG Life

NCCG Origins

NCCG Organisation

NCCG, Spirit of

NCCG Theology

NDE's

Nefilim

New Age & Occult

NCMHL

NCMM

New Covenant Torah

Norwegian Website

O

Occult Book, The

Occult Page, The

Olive Branch

Orphanages

P

Paganism, Christian

Pentecost

Poetry

Politics

Prayer

Pre-existence

Priesthood

Prophecy

Q

Questions

R

Rapture

Reincarnation

Resurrection

Revelation

RDP Page

S

Sabbath

Salvation

Satanic Ritual Abuse

Satanism

Science

Sermons & Articles

Sermons Misc

Sermonettes

Sex

Smoking

Sonship

Stewardship

Suffering

Swedish Website

T

Talmudic Judaism

Testimonies

Tithing

Tongues & Charismata

Torah

Trinity

True Church, The

TV

U

UFO's

United Order, The

V

Visions

W

Wicca & the Occult

Women

World News

Y

Yah'shua (Jesus)

Yahweh

Z

Zion


    FAQ 362
    The Feast of John 5
    Was it Purim?

    Q. Is the festival mentioned in John 1 the Feast of Lots? One Messianic ministry claims that this was Purim in AD 28 and that it must have been a Sabbath because of the invalid healed in verse 9. It claims that the only feast day to fall on a Sabbath betweeb AD 25 and 35 was Purim in AD 28. The ministry also asks: 'Did The Spirit intentionally leave out the name of the feast because the YHWH's name was deliberately left out of the Book of Esther?'

    A. "Some time later, Yah'shua (Jesus) went up to Jerusalem for a feast of the Jews. Now there is in Jerusalem near the Sheep Gate a pool, which in Aramaic is called Bethesda and which is surrounded by five covered colonnades. Here a great number of disabled people used to lie-the blind, the lame, the paralysed. One who was there had been an invalid for thirty-eight years. When Yah'shua (Jesus) saw him lying there and learned that he had been in this condition for a long time, hHe asked him, 'Do you want to get well?' 'Sir,' the invalid replied, 'I have no one to help me into the pool when the water is stirred. While I am trying to get in, someone else goes down ahead of me.' Then Yah'shua (Jesus) said to him, 'Get up! Pick up your mat and walk.' At once the man was cured; he picked up his mat and walked. The day on which this took place was a Sabbath..." (John 5:1-9, NIV).

    Firstly, the ministry in question operates using the pagan Roman solar calendar and not the biblical Creation Calendar so the estimation that Purim fell on that particular date in the year AD 28 is open to serious question. I would also like to see the calculations and how they were done before commenting further on that.

    That matter aside, I believe we can positively identify the unnamed festival in this passage as being one of the three Pilgrim Festivals of Pesach (Passover), Shavu'ot (Weeks) or Sukkot (Tabernacles) for the following reasons.

    Firstly, the actual text calls this a "Judean festival" rather than a "Jewish festival". In the ministry's own Bible translation it is even called "a feast of the Judeans" [1] rather than a "feast of the Jews" even though most Protestant and Messianic versions [2] make the mistake of giving the second rendering.

    The sense is clearly that the festival was "in Judea" or the political territory of Judah which can only mean that this was one of the three regalim or pilgrim feasts which had to be held in this specific territory. If it had simply been one of the 'feats of the Yehudim (Jews)' then it could have been held anywhere:

      "The focus here is not on the Jewishness of these festivals but on the fact that the Torah required all Jewish men to come up to 'the place Adonai your God shall choose' (Deuteronomy 16:16), which proved to be Yerushalayim in Y'hudah (Judea). Only in this verse is the festival not named. Chanukkah, a Jewish festival but not a pilgrim festival tied to Judea, is mentioned at 10:22 but is not called a Judean festival." [3]

    This very same phrase "Judean festival" or "festival in Judea/Judah" is found in ithree other places in the Gospel of John (6:4; 11:55 and a related phrase at 2:13) in connection with Pesach (Passover) and in one other (7:1-3) in connection with Sukkot (Tabernacles). It is never used in connection with the other annual festivals or the other non-mandated minor festivals like Purim or Hanukkah.

    We can conclusively state, then, that this unnamed festival in John 5:1 was either Passover, Weeks or Tabernacles. It could not have been Purim. Endnotes

    [1] Versions that use this correct rendition include the Jewish New Testament/Complete Jewish Bible (JNT/CJB), Hebraic-Roots Version (HRV) and Orthodox Jewish Bible (OJB) which renders the pharse, "feast in Yehudah"
    [2] Messianic versions that get it wrong include the Restoration Scriptures Sacred Name Version (RSTNE), Instutite for Scripture Research Version (ISRV) and the Messianic Renewed Covenant (MRC) version
    [3] David H. Stern, Jewish New Testament Commentary (Jewish New Testament Publications, Inc., Clarksville, Matyland: 1992), pp.168-167

    This page was created on 24 February 2013
    Last updated on 24 February 2013

    Copyright © 1987-2013 NCCG - All Rights Reserved